Okay, so, welcome to creepypasta.com’s weird little brother, crappypasta.com!
You’re probably wondering wtf this is, right? Let me explain.
Currently, I receive craploads (that was a thing that I did there) of stories through creepypasta.com’s submission process, often to the tune of 100+ per day. While many of them are obviously approved and posted to the main page, many more are rejected due to the same few glaring issues:
- Terrible grammar, spelling, lazy writing, an absolute lack of proofreading/editing – these are all issues that can cause even the most creative pasta ideas to be completely unreadable and unenjoyable. You may have ideas to rival the classics, but when you express them via a giant, typo-heavy wall of text, nobody is going to read it for long enough to realize that, sorry.
- Blatant rip-offs and rehashes of famous urban legends and stories already published on the site. This tends to happen when somebody sees a certain pasta getting lots of positive feedback – they think, “I can do that” and proceed to send us a very thinly veiled “remix” of the original pasta. A good example of this would be how Dead Bart spawned a thousand “lost episode” knock-off attempts. Everything from My Little Pony to Family Guy now has its version, but unfortunately, most of these copies are not very good. Plugging in your favorite cartoon + mysterious animator + clinical description of gore without adding anything new or interesting to the formula just results in people rolling their eyes and wondering whatever became of creativity.
- Obvious trolls or attempts at burning people you know IRL with stories about them. We hope that you guys high-fived before you rode off drinking Hi-C on your tricycles or whatever it is the kids do nowadays, but for the most part I barely even read these before they’re discarded.
- Authors who mistake by-the-book gore, skeletons popping out, “beautiful monsters” (fetishizing mental illness isn’t cute, and neither is romanticizing serial killers – QUIT IT), and “THEM” watching you for actual creepiness. We’ll pass over lazy writing that depends on cheap cliches any day in favor or authors who put in some actual effort.
- Stories that are not quite bad, but just lacking that certain something to make them truly delicious pastas.
I get so many requests for feedback, but the submission queue is frequently stacked several stories thousand deep. Even if I want to, there’s just no way that the I have the time and mental energy to give thoughtful critique to each rejected submission. Trust me, sometimes it’s hard to hold back when something is SO CLOSE to being approved – but I know that it’s a slippery slope and pacing myself is of the utmost importance. I can’t be all of the creepypasta fandom’s creative writing teachers, no matter how much I may love you guys!
So my attempt at a solution is crappypasta. Here, I’ll post submissions that would otherwise have gotten tossed into the rejection folder and never looked at again.
Why? For a few reasons – here comes another list!
- So that people can comment, rate, and provide feedback on the stories that aren’t quite right, but could be postable to the main site with some editing and rewrites.
- Sometimes we’re just wrong and might reject a story that actually wasn’t that bad.
- Because you tried, and you deserve that gold star, dammit.
So that’s basically it. Don’t worry, every submission that is posted on crappypasta is here with the author’s EXPLICIT permission; there’s a nifty little check-yes-or-no question about this site in the creepypasta.com submission form.
If your submission is posted here, don’t get mad. Learn from the comments. If you have the drive and patience, take the advice given by the readers here and rewrite your story and re-submit it to the main site; we have no objections to upgrading a crappypasta into a creepypasta if you put in the work and truly make it better, or if the vast majority of readers think that it was not, in fact, a crappypasta in the first place.
Also: while I appreciate your enthusiasm, please do NOT submit pastas to the main site with the sole intent of getting them on Crappypasta. It clogs up my submission queue and ignores the purpose of this site, as well as reeking of forced tryhard, which means that there’s a 99% chance that your fake crappypasta isn’t nearly as funny as you think it is.
So enjoy the crappypasta, and I hope that this is an entertaining and educational experience… or something like that.